In the dynamic world of Major League Baseball, the question of who stands as the best player on the Pittsburgh Pirates at any given moment is one that stirs passionate debate among fans, analysts, and enthusiasts alike. The Pirates, with their rich history and dedicated fan base, have had their fair share of standout performers over the years. But as we focus on the present, determining the current top player requires a comprehensive look at various factors, from on-field performance metrics to the intangible qualities that elevate a player's impact on the team.
Analyzing On-Field Performance Metrics
Hitting Statistics
One of the primary ways to evaluate a player's performance is through their hitting numbers. Batting average, on-base percentage (OBP), slugging percentage (SLG), and OPS (on-base plus slugging) are key indicators. For example, if a player is consistently hitting for a high average, getting on base frequently, and driving the ball with power, they are likely making a significant contribution to the team's offense. In the 2024 season, some Pirates players had impressive hitting streaks. Connor Joe, in the early part of the season, led the team with a .292 batting average in March and April, along with three home runs, eight doubles, and 14 runs batted in. His OPS during that period reached .853, and his wRC+ (weighted runs created plus) climbed to 136. However, his performance tailed off later in the season.
On the other hand, players like Bryan Reynolds have shown more consistent excellence at the plate. In July 2024, Reynolds had a wRC+ of 152, an OPS of .909 (with an on-base percentage of .391 and a slugging percentage of .518), and he belted five home runs while driving in 15 runs. His ability to maintain a high level of offensive production throughout different parts of the season makes him a strong candidate for the title of the best hitter on the team.
Pitching Metrics
For pitchers, earned run average (ERA), fielding independent pitching (FIP), strikeout-to-walk ratio (K/BB), and WHIP (walks plus hits per inning pitched) are crucial metrics. Mitch Keller had a remarkable June in 2024. Across 30.2 innings, he posted an ERA of 2.35 and an FIP of 2.94. He struck out 33 batters while walking opponents at a 6.1% clip, resulting in a WHIP of 1.17. His dominance during that month was a significant factor in the Pirates' performance. In contrast, a pitcher with a high ERA and a poor K/BB ratio may be struggling to contribute positively to the team.
Defensive Contributions
Fielding Percentage and Range
A player's defensive skills can't be overlooked. Fielding percentage measures a player's ability to handle balls hit their way without making errors. A high fielding percentage indicates reliability in the field. Additionally, a player's range, or their ability to cover a large area of the field, can be a game-changer. For instance, an outfielder with exceptional speed and quick reactions can make diving catches and prevent extra-base hits, saving runs for the team. In the infield, a shortstop or second baseman with great range can turn double plays more effectively, getting the team out of tough situations.
Impact on Team Morale
Defensive plays that save runs or change the momentum of a game can have a profound impact on team morale. A spectacular catch in the outfield or a diving stop in the infield can energize the entire team and demoralize the opposing side. Players who consistently make these types of defensive contributions are not only valuable for their on-field skills but also for their ability to lift the spirits of their teammates.
Intangible Qualities
Leadership on and off the Field
A great player often serves as a leader within the team. This can manifest in various ways, such as mentoring younger players, setting a positive example through hard work and dedication, and making calm and strategic decisions during high-pressure situations. A team captain, for example, may be the one to rally the troops in the dugout during a tough game or offer words of encouragement to a struggling teammate. Leadership is not limited to the vocal leaders; some players lead by example with their consistent performance and professionalism.
Clutch Performance
The ability to perform well in high-leverage situations is another intangible quality that sets the best players apart. Clutch hitters are those who can come through with a big hit when the game is on the line, perhaps with runners in scoring position and two outs in the late innings. Clutch pitchers can shut down the opposing team's offense when their team has a slim lead or needs to prevent a comeback. These players thrive under pressure and their performances can be the difference between a win and a loss.
Current Candidates for the Title
Oneil Cruz
Oneil Cruz had an outstanding August in 2024. He finished the month with an OPS of .985 and a season-low strikeout percentage of 23.4%. His wRC+ reached 171, and he batted .389. He also belted a home run and nine doubles, while stealing 10 bases. Cruz's combination of power, speed, and improved plate discipline made him a force to be reckoned with during that month. His ability to impact the game in multiple ways, both offensively and on the base paths, makes him a strong candidate for the title of the best Pirates player right now.
Paul Skenes
As the National League Rookie of the Year winner, Paul Skenes had a dominant end to the 2024 season. In September and October, across 24 innings, he posted an ERA of 0.75 and an FIP of 1.21. He struck out 34 batters, while opposing hitters batted only .186 against him with a slugging percentage of .198. His WHIP was an impressive 0.92. Skenes' ability to dominate opposing lineups as a rookie gives hope for the future of the Pirates' pitching staff and firmly places him in the conversation for the best player on the team currently.
Determining the best Pirates player right now is no easy feat. It requires a careful consideration of a player's offensive and defensive performance, as well as their intangible qualities. Whether it's a hitter like Bryan Reynolds, a pitcher like Mitch Keller, or emerging stars like Oneil Cruz and Paul Skenes, each player brings their own unique set of skills and contributions to the team. As the season progresses, the landscape may change, but for now, these players stand out as some of the top performers on the Pittsburgh Pirates.